Gill Linton: Fashion Democracy And The Marketing Hall Of Naff

Gill Linton: Fashion Democracy And The Marketing Hall Of Naff

When it comes to marketing, broadly speaking, the fashion industry is frankly a bit naff, (for my American friends; naff adjective Brit., informal lacking taste or style.)

Gill Linton
  • 27 april 2010

When it comes to marketing, broadly speaking, the fashion industry is frankly a bit naff, (for my American friends; naff adjective Brit., informal lacking taste or style.)

Naff, in the same way that the masses latch on to the latest trend and ruin it for the rest of us. And while I recognize this is part of the cycle of natural selection that leads to cultural change, there’s still so much more of the lowest common denominator kind than the meaningful and creatively extra-ordinary.

I’m mostly disappointed by how it latches on to the latest marketing buzzwords and technical possibilities to get more clicks.

For the record, my top 4 marketing naff list is:

4. Consumer generated content, otherwise known as a promotion or cheap stunt. Otherwise known as a bribe for eyeballs.

3. Viral films. It’s not a film it’s an ad. Calling it a film doesn’t make it any more effective.

2. Branded content. A long ad.

1. Online magazines. It’s not a magazine. It’s a cut and paste sales brochure or another blog banging on about Lady Gaga.

It all boils down to chasing eyeballs. I’m on the side of the fence that believes this is a meaningless measure of a good or bad idea. I also believe that people should pay for quality online media products and services, and that paywalls separate the good from the, well, naff. It might result in a smaller number of impressions, but in terms of efficiency, its got to be a better quality conversion.

In an online world dominated by fast and free mediocrity, the purpose and role of a brand is more important that ever. And while the decision to charge or not to charge is still uncharted territory, is not charging a sign of insecurity about what makes one brands output better than another? And I purposefully mean better not different. That line on a creative brief that says, ‘What makes the brand different?’ It should read ‘What makes the brand better.’

Can we please move on from the online democracy age (the hall of naff), and into an era of online quality and closed walls (‘gasp, stone her!’ they cried), where discerning people value the extra-ordinary and the only thing that is democratic, is that quality gets a meaningful paycheck. There’s a reason why HBO is consistently brilliant and why the BBC is the most revered news and entertainment media brand in the world. People pay for it.

I’m not suggesting that fashion brands start charging for the content they produce, the online content they produce is cost of marketing, (although I believe that all brands should have revenue streams beyond their core business, but that’s a whole other article.)

My point about chasing eyeballs vs. quality is the same. My hope is that more fashion brands will approach the possibilities created by new technology with the same degree of thought and integrity they put into design. Instead, churning stuff out quickly, because that’s the accepted nature of the digital beast, with nothing to say.

Anthony Sperduti and Andy Spade of Partners & Spade spoke about big brand behavior in a real retail world, at the PSFK conference. I asked Anthony how brands should behave in the virtual world.

“The online space is no different than any other vehicle for communication or marketing – can be used with intelligence or used as a gimmick. The lure of some of the new technology (and buzzwords) seems for some brands to have generated more gimmicks unfortunately. The exciting part of the online world that it’s opening up to us is the ability to speak with depth to the consumer. Things do not have to be: 30 sound bites – or single headlines or glossy images – there is a much lower cost of entry for potentially a much larger mind share. Even the smallest brands now have an ability to tell their complete, nuanced point of view and the successful ones will be those that understand that. Like using retail as a marketing tool as much as a point of distribution, savvy brands will learn to tell their story well and truly connect with their customers.”

Take the Burberry 3D fashion show, which included a ‘pre-show event.’ An example of where technology drove their decision – to their own admission during the pre-show itself, they only decided to do it a few months before – not the quality of their message and creativity. And it showed. The collection itself was flawlessly brilliant in design and production. While Christopher Bailey stole the show, the rest of it was a cringe worthy insight into a world where marketing and design collided and marketing won. I don’t know that to be true, but in trying so hard to create authentic content, the savvy fashion audience giggled their way through a fashion 101 marketing infomercial of paid for celebrity interviews hanging by a thread of awkward silences.

Joe Frydl is a co-founder of Indigenous Entertainment – a company that creates entertainment driven marketing programs on behalf of brand and media clients. Joe has a more charitable and forgiving view of the Burberry show, and thinks that,

“While it may not be the slickest or the most carefully produced material, it does have some things going for it, they did I, it’s timely, as a result, it has an immediacy to it. They got stuck in and are in the mix by trying to get something to their audience so that they can share in an experience that normally would be unavailable to them. Granted, every label streamed their show this year so no big points for huge originality.

When I see something as well planned and executed as “The Art of the Trench”, I’m more forgiving with things like this. They are TRYING when a lot of brands just can’t even leave the starting blocks with content. I’m sure they got some great education from doing this and I bet the next time will be better. Pollyanish? Perhaps. But just like the best TV and Film producers, the key is to keep at it. Not arguing for throwing everything against the wall to see what sticks, but sometimes we get a little too precious and frozen with analysis paralysis.”

I’m sure a lot of people saw it. How democratic.

Gill Linton- Fashion Democracy And The Marketing Hall Of Naff-2

Rumors after the event were that Burberry was not happy that Kate Hudson didn’t wear the Burberry coat they gave her, having paid for her to be there.

Gill writes about the business of fashion for Mpdclick – a leading commercial online fashion trend forecasting service. To discover more, please visit

Gill is a creative strategy consultant in New York. Contact her at


Fitness Advocate: Paving The Future of Workouts With Audio

Fitness & Sport
Food Today

Tiny Pub Only Has Space For Three People

Make Time For It is a small London pop-up bar that encourages conversation without the distraction of technology

Work Today

Community Builder: How to Hack Slack

Claire Wasserman, Founder of Ladies Get Paid, describes how she's using an internal team communication tool to build a network of thousands


Get PSFK's Related Report: Future of Automotive

See All
Advertising Today

This Beer Was Brewed Just For Scotch Drinkers

Highland Park Scotch Whisky & Sixpoint Brewery have teamed up to create two limited-edition pairings for New York City boilermakers

Related Expert

Erica Kochi

Development, Social Good, Technology

Mobile Today

Pizza Hut Tattoo Lets You Place An Order From Your Body

The latest gimmick from the fast-food chain is a tattoo-like sticker that lets customers get delivery with a simple tap on their arm

Travel Today

Reinvented Bicycle Inspired By Supercar Design

The yellow bike based on a Lamborghini has sharp edges and an aluminum alloy frame

Health Today

Health Platform Gives Perspective On Your Weekly Habits

Gyroscope is a new wellness app that works by amalgamating data about your life into beautifully designed visuals


Future Of Automotive
Scenarios Driving The Digital Transformation Of An Industry

PSFK Op-Ed october 21, 2016

Health Expert: Nutritional Meal Replacements Are A Solution To Corporate Wellness

Ample Foods Founder Connor Young explains why supplements are the next food trend coming to the workplace

PSFK Labs october 21, 2016

PSFK Picks: Top 5 Performance-Enhancing Wearables

Our new report looks at innovations pioneering the future of performance through intelligent activewear and predictive analytics

Beauty Today

Korean Beauty Brand Uses VR To Let Customers Pick Their Ingredients

Innisfree created a unique experience for its Shanghai Disneyland customers with a virtual reality trip to select what goes into their purchase

Design & Architecture Today

3D-Printed Creations Resemble Floating Paper Outlines

Japanese design firm Nendo's exhibition features works that look like sheets of material being folded, torn, and crumpled

Technology october 21, 2016

Concept Camera Designed To Only Take Unique Photos

Camera Restricta is tool that prompts photographers to only capture one-of-a-kind images

Design & Architecture october 21, 2016

Dubai And The Future Of Humanitarian Design

In its second year, Global Grad Show brings together 145 cracks at a more sustainable, connected and empowered way of living

Retail october 21, 2016

LYNK & CO Is A New Auto Brand That Promises Mobile Connectivity On Wheels

Online access and mobility sharing are driving the company to disrupt the auto industry

Gaming & Play october 21, 2016

Nintendo’s New Console Pushes For Portable Gaming

The Switch allows gamers to seamlessly play on the go by themselves or with friends

No search results found.