The Displacement Of Film Criticism By Online Aggregators

The Displacement Of Film Criticism By Online Aggregators

Is the "fanboy blogosphere" and online review aggregator sites such as Rotten Tomatoes forcing individual film criticism into extinction?

Dylan Schenker
  • 4 january 2011

There is growing concern within the world of film journalism that review aggregator sites such as Rotten Tomatoes are forcing individual film criticism into extinction. Since the very nature of such sites is to tabulate a percentage based on perceived positive or negative reviews, the actual critique is typically lost except for a single line quote from the author.

Rotten Tomatoes editor-in-chief, Matt Atchity, rejects this proposition,

“I understand it and I know there are people who just read the number,” he says. “But ultimately, I think that we do good by exposing readers and users to criticism that they wouldn’t otherwise have access to. We hope the Tomatometer is a launching point for a larger read of critics.”

Also of concern is the proliferation of critics that belong to the tightly associated so-called fanboy blogosphere. Sites such as Aint it Cool News, Cinematical & JoBlo are perceived to have markedly different values than many more seasoned critics who began their careers in print publications. This apparent discrepancy is evinced when considering the difference between the overall Tomato Score and the Top Critics Score.

Armond White, critic for the New York Press, is the most outspoken critic of the blogosphere considering the increasingly vocal community to be the representative of a scourge of anti-intellectualism in the field of film journalism.

While claims of anti-intellectualism may be blown out of proportion, it is apparent that both kinds of critics have a strong influence on the ratings on the site. In many cases the fresh or rotten ratings have the potential to increase the significance or popularity of different kinds of films whether they be Hollywood fare or more inaccessible art house cinema.

Rotten Tomatoes

IndieWire: “Fresh or Rotten Tomatoes for Film Culture: Discuss”


Wearable Tech Expert: Designing Technology To Empower Connection To Ourselves

Technology Today

Album Turns Into Something New Each Time It’s Streamed

Bill Baird's new album explores the relationship between time and music through a website crafted by design team, One Pixel Wide

Technology Today

Wearable Device And Lamp Recreate Beautiful Sunsets In Your Home

Sun Memories can record up to six hours of natural light and reproduce it via a connected light at a later date


Get PSFK's Related Report: Future of Automotive

See All
Design & Architecture Today

Flower Pencils Create Cherry Blossom Petals When Sharpened

A Japanese stationary company developed the special implements in order to create unique shavings

Augmented & Virtual Reality Today

The Simpsons Is Stepping Into The World Of VR

To celebrate their 600th episode, the animated family sitcom created a virtual reality version of their opening gag

Syndicated Yesterday

Museum Exhibit Celebrates Strange Architectural Contraptions

Artist William Heath Robinson's peculiar genius is on display in this recent show with wiggling ducts, jumbles of planks and coils of cable

Food Yesterday

This Sensor Will Help You Brew The Perfect Cup Of Tea Every Time

42Tea is a small device that guides you through every step of the brewing process, even identifying the type of leaves being used

Design & Architecture Yesterday

Norwegian Mountaineering Center Mimics A Snow-Capped Mountain

The structure's exterior is clad in a uniform surface of pixels to create a unique climbing experience


Future Of Automotive
Scenarios Driving The Digital Transformation Of An Industry

PSFK Op-Ed october 17, 2016

Home Depot Green Energy Expert: Americans Are Taking Control Of Their Power Use

Green tech expert Jennifer Tuohy discusses new home energy tech and developments for renewables in the US

PSFK Labs october 12, 2016

PSFK Picks: Top 5 Performance-Enhancing Wearables

Our new report looks at innovations pioneering the future of performance through intelligent activewear and predictive analytics

Gaming & Play Yesterday

Shopping Bag Turns Your Hands Into A LEGO

Designers from the School of Visual Arts thought up the Playbox Bag for a competition

Sustainability Yesterday

Giant Coffee Cups Encourage People To Recycle Their Morning Cup Of Joe

The Hubbub Foundation has created a set of themed bins meant to inspire recycling on a large scale

Home Yesterday

Small Device Creates A Personal Weather Station Inside In Your Home

Netatmo's new sensor is a standalone air quality monitor that can measure humidity, purity, noise and temperature

Travel Yesterday

Advertising Proposal Aims To Be The Most “Instagrammable Billboard In The World”

The Belltower in Los Angeles would allow video advertising and live event streaming, and include a pedestrian plaza for visitors

Beauty Yesterday

L’Oréal Wants To Help Visually Impaired Women Apply Makeup

The cosmetics brand has developed a series of audio tutorials for Brazilian consumers with reduced sight

Travel Yesterday

Drone-Powered Hotel Concept Could Radically Redefine Vacations

These unique pods would allow guests to visit a variety of locales over a period of several days

Automotive Yesterday

Pitch Your Startup Idea To Fellow Uber Passengers

A new promotion on the ridesharing service's POOL feature lets select riders compete for a $5,000 investment from prominent venture capitalists

No search results found.