Regulation Will Always Play Catch Up To The Computer’s Rules

Regulation Will Always Play Catch Up To The Computer’s Rules

The problem of how to run business models in a world of digital savants, hackers and maker culture is a fraught one. Cory Doctorow provides an important reflection on the root causes of this issue.

Stephen Fortune
  • 11 april 2011

Old approaches to regulation are likely to be increasingly redundant in the face of the transformations ubiquitous digital iterability will cause to many industries. But even in areas where it’s methods are ill suited, the mechanisms of regulation can still exert a considerable degree of force, but Cory Doctorow argues the time has come to give serious consideration to who will feel the weight of that force most.

Contemporary technological advancements and an increasingly prominent ‘Maker’ (and Hacker) Culture are likely to see regulation wrangles kick things up several notches in coming years. To gain some insight into the paths regulation will follow Doctorow infers a parallel with the MP3 and copyright infringement battles of yesteryear. This industry crisis illustrated that the principles upon which the universal computer (and by extension the networks run on these computers) operates simply cannot foreclose the possibility of these unanticipated and industry challenging usages occurring.

And with regards to regulation, the fallout of the filesharing wars is also instructive:

It proved that prohibition is remarkably ineffective at stopping people who really want to get through. Even the staunchest defendants of anti-copying technology and network blocks will tell you that they are intended as “speed bumps” that will discourage casual filesharers

Nowadays the speed bumps are becoming more sophisticated (World of Warcraft comes bundled with spyware that can examine and tamper with every file on the player’s computer, in the name of preventing cheaters), but they can still be circumnavigated by those who are savvy about how their computers operate. And unfortunately sidestepping these control measures isn’t always a mere act of ‘sticking it to the man.’ This sidestepping can also easily be used to exploit customers who may not even be aware of the presence of such software on their computers.

For each of these control measures, the question isn’t whether they’ll fail, but when they will, and who will hijack their capabilities.

This is where the ethical question of regulation presents itself. The spyware model will deter casual deviants but it will provide little more than a hurdle for those who really want to get through. And the means by which the spyware model operates will then afford the determined subverters more means to exploit other machines, should they wish to do so.

Today’s business world is full of companies that have built their fortunes on the idea of designing a computer that can only run certain approved programs. But building a computer that can run every program is infinitely simpler than building a computer that can run any program except for naughty ones… (and) it’s because the potential for harm is so great that we can’t afford to put our faith in magic computer-controlling technology

Doctorow’s article considers how the problem of industry protection versus customer protection applies to future technologies such as  bio-printers that can output organisms, pharmaceutical compounds, and biological material.

Cory Doctorow

The Guardian: “Beware the Spyware Model of Technology–Its Flaws are Built In”


Wearable Tech Expert: Designing Technology To Empower Connection To Ourselves

Syndicated Today

Museum Exhibit Celebrates Strange Architectural Contraptions

Artist William Heath Robinson's peculiar genius is on display in this recent show with wiggling ducts, jumbles of planks and coils of cable

Technology Today

This Sensor Will Help You Brew The Perfect Cup Of Tea Every Time

42Tea is a small device that guides you through every step of the brewing process, even identifying the type of leaves being used


Get PSFK's Related Report: Future of Automotive

See All
Design & Architecture Today

Norwegian Mountaineering Center Mimics A Snow-Capped Mountain

The structure's exterior is clad in a uniform surface of pixels to create a unique climbing experience

Related Expert

Ben Lerer

Media, Lifestyle, Venture Capital

Sustainability Today

Giant Coffee Cups Encourage People To Recycle Their Morning Cup Of Joe

The Hubbub Foundation has created a set of themed bins meant to inspire recycling on a large scale

Home Today

Small Device Creates A Personal Weather Station Inside In Your Home

Netatmo's new sensor is a standalone air quality monitor that can measure humidity, purity, noise and temperature

Travel Today

Advertising Proposal Aims To Be The Most “Instagrammable Billboard In The World”

The Belltower in Los Angeles would allow video advertising and live event streaming, and include a pedestrian plaza for visitors


Future Of Automotive
Scenarios Driving The Digital Transformation Of An Industry

PSFK Op-Ed october 17, 2016

Home Depot Green Energy Expert: Americans Are Taking Control Of Their Power Use

Green tech expert Jennifer Tuohy discusses new home energy tech and developments for renewables in the US

PSFK Labs october 12, 2016

PSFK Picks: Top 5 Performance-Enhancing Wearables

Our new report looks at innovations pioneering the future of performance through intelligent activewear and predictive analytics

Design & Architecture Today

Easy-To-Build Shelter Offers A Quick Way To Put A Roof Above Your Head

The structure designed by studio Duffy London has applications in disaster relief or first-aid

Beauty Today

L’Oréal Wants To Help Visually Impaired Women Apply Makeup

The cosmetics brand has developed a series of audio tutorials for Brazilian consumers with reduced sight

Travel Today

Drone-Powered Hotel Concept Could Radically Redefine Vacations

These unique pods would allow guests to visit a variety of locales over a period of several days

Automotive Today

Pitch Your Startup Idea To Fellow Uber Passengers

A new promotion on the ridesharing service's POOL feature lets select riders compete for a $5,000 investment from prominent venture capitalists

Work Today

Busy Office Managers Can Rely Upon A Digital Concierge To Help Offload Tasks

MEET is a service that automates the process of everyday tasks such as pantry and printer reordering, so employees can focus on more important work

Media & Publishing Today

Design Series Turns Emojis Into A Coffee Table Book

The Emoji Book will be comprised of different artist interpretations of the ubiquitous symbols

Health Today

These Pajamas Are Promising A Better Night’s Sleep

Recliner's new collection is made for those looking for a better way to get quality shut-eye

Food Today

Cook An Entire Pizza On Your Stovetop

This compact kitchen appliance lets people bake a homemade pie without the need for an oven

No search results found.