Digital Idolatry And The Limits Of Social Media

Digital Idolatry And The Limits Of Social Media

What is social media doing to our memory and relationships? How will technologists solve for its shortcomings in the coming years?

Plus Aziz
  • 18 may 2011


Discussing the shortcomings of social media should not automatically be taken dismissed as an attack on technology. In a recent article titled The Twitter Trap, New York Times Executive Editor Bill Keller accounts for how early printing technology has weakened human memory.

We’re cyborgs in that we rely entirely on various tools and machines to perform jobs, to communicate, to express how we feel. The essential question becomes are we ‘outsourcing our brains to the cloud?’

The new technologies overtaking us may be eroding characteristics that are essentially human: our ability to reflect, our pursuit of meaning, genuine empathy, a sense of community connected by something deeper than snark or political affinity.

Keller’s main question is: as socialized beings, what are we unlearning when Facebook “friendships” and Twitter buzz displace “real rapport and real conversation?” He quotes UCLA psychologist Robert Bjork “Unless there is some actual problem solving and decision making, very little learning happens.”  So what types of decisions are you making and problems are you solving when you’re on your favorite social networks?

Taking the opposite side of the spectrum, Jenna Wortham reflects on how social networks have strengthened her yearning for in-person interaction with her friends:

For me, the exact opposite has happened. The stream of pleasantries, links and comments that I exchange online have only served to heighten my craving for in-person interactions at the end of the day….Wishing a friend happy birthday on Facebook, Twitter or Tumblr doesn’t stop me from showing up at their party.”

She then makes a great point about how its become easier to introduce ourselves to influential content producers :

Facebook and Twitter make us more curious to meet and chat with the people we’ve encountered online… I can’t imagine I would have been bold enough to introduce myself or strike up a conversation had we not built up a kind of camaraderie on Twitter in the weeks before.

Mr.Keller does see the development of social media networks as a great thing; he works for a publisher that was quick to adopt emerging technology. But his view is also precocious, reminiscent of Malcolm Gladwell’s “The Revolution Will Not Be Tweeted.” Keller goes on to describe social media as “aggressive distractions,” pointing out that Twitter “demands attention and response. It is the enemy of contemplation,” fostering a consistent “failure to connect.” To what extent is this true or false? Is this inherent to social media or an outcome of the fact that it’s still in its infancy?

Thus far, both the Egyptian revolution earlier this year and Obama’s 2008 presidential campaign demonstrate how social media can be effective in driving towards a focused goal (i.e. vote, donate, meet here); but the momentum quickly fizzles out. Such case studies demonstrate that ‘radical change’ cannot be sustained by ‘radical technology’ despite the fact that the physical and virtual world are intimately connected and mutually supportive of each other.  Many believe that it’s still politics as usual in Washington D.C. and that Egypt’s desire for democracy is significantly challenged.

Thus, the point still remains to be disproved, that however you use social media, if you want to generate critical thinking, see progressive initiatives actualize, garner heated debates with constructive outcomes, or nurture deep discussion, take the conversation offline or at least get on the phone. This can be seen as either the crux of social media’s limit or a fundamental challenge that creative technologists will solve for in the coming years.

New York Times:”The Twitter Trap”

The New Yorker: “The Revolution Will Not Be Tweeted”

New York Times: “Does Facebook Help or Hinder  Offline Friendship?”


Editorial Roundtable: What A People-First Workplace Must Prioritize First

Syndicated Yesterday

What Could The Highway Of The Future Look Like?

As technology for automated vehicles improves, there’s a sharper focus on building a ‘smarter’ infrastructure where they can thrive

Design Yesterday

Plastic Wind Trees Are Bringing Sustainable Power To Residential Homes

These French-made turbines are offering a small, aesthetically pleasing approach to affordable personal energy


Get PSFK's Latest Report: Future of Retail: Technology Primer

See All
Home Yesterday

Dyson’s Wi-Fi Connected Fan Purifies, Cools & Heats The Air

The new luxury home appliance aims to be an all-in-one device for the connected home

Education Yesterday

Bringing Virtual Reality And Telepresence Robotics To E-Learning

This Learning Management System is embracing new technologies to reallocate teaching resources to where they should be going


Elon Musk

Solar Power, Battery Technology, Sustainability

Advertising Yesterday

Brewing Company Turns Car Emissions Into Ink

Tiger Beer has created a sustainable process to transform air pollution into supplies for street art

Design Yesterday

Space-Saving Sofa Has Extra Furniture Hidden Inside

Living in an apartment with limited space? This three-in-one bed transforms based on your needs

Culture Yesterday

Browser Extension Blocks Any Pages That Make You Unhappy

The software can detect your facial movements and prevent content that brings up negative emotions


Future Of Work
Cultivating The Next Generation Of Leaders

PSFK Op-Ed august 25, 2016

Retail Expert: What Sustainability Means To The Millennial Generation

Jo Godden, Founder of RubyMoon, discusses how brands can limit their environmental impact worldwide

PSFK Labs august 25, 2016

PSFK’s Workplace Vision: How The Nurturing Of Seeds Will Come To Define The Onboarding Process

Our Future of Work vision is a service that allows companies to assemble and deliver welcome packets that are uniquely focused on the concept of growth

Automotive Yesterday

Reserve Your Parking Spot Before You Even Get Behind The Wheel

A new Ford app allows drivers to select and arrange for a space in a garage to be available at the end of their journey, so they can travel worry-free

Work Yesterday

PSFK’s Workplace Vision: The Desk Is Becoming An Ecosystem Of Satellite Workstations

Our Future of Work vision is an app that frees employees from the tyranny of a static desk

Food Yesterday

A Tiny Amount Of This Powder Could Block All The Bitterness In Food

A new substance made from mushrooms can bond with taste receptors on your tongue to overcome unpleasant flavors

Asia Yesterday

Whimsical Dental Clinic Design Aims To Calm Patient Fears

Cheerful colors and a nod to the comforts of home are design elements tactfully aimed to help people relax

Mobile Yesterday

Messenger Service Only Delivers You Updates Three Times A Day

Formal is a new app designed to help people ignore the constant stream of texts from their phone and focus on what's in front of them


Rio Olympics
Innovation Coverage From The Rio Games

Design Yesterday

Movable Vacation House Constructed Using Concrete Boxes

The 4,000 square foot building is made up of modular frames so it can be relocated if needed due to coastline erosion

Design Yesterday

Redesigned Electric Fan Collapses For Easy Storage

Conbox can be kept in pieces and packed away when not in use

Ai Yesterday

LawyerBot Is Now Helping Homeless People Qualify For Government Housing

This robot helps people get out of parking tickets and provides free legal advice to those in need

No search results found.