Jonathan’s Card Shuttered By Starbucks But Revived In ‘Sequel’ Experiment

Jonathan’s Card Shuttered By Starbucks But Revived In ‘Sequel’ Experiment

While one consultant's social experiment in generosity became another programmer's experiment in the re-allocation (and re-valuation) of collective funding, what are the security implications?

Paloma M. Vazquez
  • 16 august 2011

We were alerted (thank you, M. Ristori) to the unfortunate fact that Jonathan’s Card — mobile application consultant Jonathan Stark‘s experiment in human generosity, digital currency and mobile payments — has been forced by Starbucks to shut down after one programmer (Sam Odio) demonstrated just how accessible funding of a ‘shared’ account is, by writing a script that alerted him as to when a substantial donation was made. This allowed Odio to access and re-deploy the funds to another account. He ultimately decided to ‘sell’ the money he transferred out of Jonathan’s Card as a $500 card on eBay, with the intent that proceeds would ultimately be donated to Save the Children.

In essence, by ‘redirecting’ contributors’ money from their intended account (and from the purpose of its collectively generous benefit), Odio’s version of an ‘experiment’ (determining if people will bid up the price of his card – consisting of other people’s money, redirected for a different purpose than originally intended) contributed to Stark’s card’s shutdown by encroaching on card account security (and alarming Starbucks).

Of course, some of us just can’t let sleeping dogs lie. Talk About Design alerted us to their proactive desire to revisit and continue Stark’s experiment. In this iteration, rather than releasing an API for open, transparent tracking of the card’s balance, Talk About Design will post updates to the balance – and invite contributors to donate – while posting the balance and barcode on their site. According to Talk About Design:

After learning about Jonathan’s Card, we started providing you with live balance updates and ability to donate. Sadly due to one person’s greed, Starbucks was forced to shut down Jonathan’s Card. Well it’s not over folks. My guess is that Jonathan made a big mistake by releasing API to keep track of a card’s balance. We will do no such thing. Currently we are working on processing this data on our end and then posting the results here.

Rather than engage in a battle of who’s right and wrong and whose intentions are pure vs. not, we take a more practical view and wonder not only what these experiments say about human generosity, but also what they say about the security of financial transactions online. After all, if a programmer can find a loophole based on a photograph of a barcode (and money collectively donated to that single card/account), how simple might it be to make a photograph of any barcode or account information essentially transactional to the public?

[via Jonathan’s Card, Sam Odio and Talk About Design]


Dubai And The Future Of Humanitarian Design

Design & Architecture
Technology october 21, 2016

Concept Camera Designed To Only Take Unique Photos

Camera Restricta is tool that prompts photographers to only capture one-of-a-kind images

Design & Architecture october 21, 2016

Fragrance Will Release The Smell Of Data If Your Private Information Is Being Leaked

The device is designed to create a physical cue for the potential dangers lurking online


Get PSFK's Related Report: Future of Automotive

See All
Retail october 21, 2016

LYNK & CO Is A New Auto Brand That Promises Mobile Connectivity On Wheels

Online access and mobility sharing are driving the company to disrupt the auto industry

Related Expert

Gill Linton

Brand Strategist, Fashion Entrepreneur

Travel october 21, 2016

Become A Citizen Of The First Nation In Space

Asgardia is a new concept for a floating society above Earth

Entertainment october 21, 2016

Speaker Displays Song Lyrics As Music Is Played

The device is able to generate the graphics on a translucent screen and retrieve the words from a connected database

AI october 21, 2016

Travel Assistant Scans Your Emails To Make Planning Easier

This AI add-on will sync with your inbox and sends reminders to make sure you don't miss anything important


Future Of Automotive
Scenarios Driving The Digital Transformation Of An Industry

PSFK Op-Ed october 20, 2016

Wearable Tech Expert: Designing Technology To Empower Connection To Ourselves

Billie Whitehouse, Founder of Wearable Experiments, shares her new vision for the quantified self

PSFK Labs october 21, 2016

PSFK Picks: Top 5 Performance-Enhancing Wearables

Our new report looks at innovations pioneering the future of performance through intelligent activewear and predictive analytics

Millennials october 21, 2016

FOMO Survival Kit Helps Millennials Cope With Social Anxieties

The satirical product is meant to be a playful diversion for people who feel like they are missing out

Food october 21, 2016

New York Restaurant Uses Tomato Sushi As Its Newest Meat Alternative

fresh&co is using sous vide Roma tomatoes to create a vegan option that has the texture and taste of tuna

Advertising october 21, 2016

Red Bull Converts Sao Paulo Payphones Into Data-Driven Bus Schedules

The booths allow city residents to check local transit times through a simple toll-free phone call

Work october 21, 2016

Health Expert: Nutritional Meal Replacements Are A Solution To Corporate Wellness

Ample Foods Founder Connor Young explains why supplements are the next food trend coming to the workplace

Retail october 21, 2016

Why Experiential Events Could Replace Trade Shows

Marketers are seeking creative and impactful new ways to connect with influencers

Children october 21, 2016

Modular Kit Teaches Kids How To Make Their Own Robots

MODI features magnetic modules and a platform for programming to encourage experimentation

Infants october 21, 2016

Work Table Doubles As A Baby Seat

Designer Kunsik Choi created the furniture to facilitate emotional communication between between parents and their children

Technology october 21, 2016

Album Turns Into Something New Each Time It’s Streamed

Bill Baird's new album explores the relationship between time and music through a website crafted by design team, One Pixel Wide

No search results found.