menu

Piers Fawkes: Nike Thinks I’m The Athlete I’m Not

Piers Fawkes: Nike Thinks I’m The Athlete I’m Not
technology

The tracking accuracy on new Nike Fuel band is suspect and the brand's view of health is naive.

Piers Fawkes, PSFK
  • 24 february 2012

I was lucky enough to be presented with a free Nike Fuel earlier this week. The sporting apparel company had set up a huge exhibition in a warehouse on a pier in Manhattan that edged into the East River. A row of Nike employees helped me and, I guess, other ‘influencers’ set up their Fuel wristbands and set ourselves personal goals.

I got a medium band. It fit snuggly around my right wrist. It’s a kind of pedometer that uses an accelerometer to calculate steps taken, calories burned and ‘Nike Fuel’ points. It has a one button interface that allows the user to scroll through a glowing display. It also has a USB that allows the band to both charge and upload data to somewhere in the cloud.

Some readers may know that I’m curious about self-tracking and its impact on health. Last week, I wrote about my experience with The Eatery app which I used to photo-journal my diet during a week-long trip to London. So, I was interested in seeing how Nike Fuel could impact my health as well.

After a day wearing the device, however, I began to distrust the tracking accuracy and felt that the device lacked the complexity that we are beginning to expect when it comes to mobile technology and our health. I just expected more from a large corporation with deep pockets for investment.

With a goal of hitting a rigorous 3,000 Nike Fuel points, here’s how my day unfolded on Thursday:

6am – Morning starts with daily research. Nike Fuel points – 85

7am – Lego distraction with daughter Georgie. Nike Fuel points – 227. RSS has been hard work!

8am – Cy tries on the Nike Fuel band at breakfast. Crikey, he should have his clothes on by now. Nike Fuel points – 405. Must have been the oatmeal stirring.

9am – One’s off to school, the other is crying in the background of this conference call to Italy. Nike Fuel points – 660. Wonder how much energy I will burn speaking English loud and slowly for the next 45 minutes?

10am – Got to get to the office. Let’s see how many steps it takes to make the 25 minute walk. Steps already taken this morning: 1695. What? I’ve already paced around the apartment over fifteen hundred times? Maybe it was chasing all those little monkeys.

10.28am – Made it to the office just in time. Steps – 3936. That means I walked 2,241 steps for a 1.2 mile journey. I looked this stat up and it seemed like an average

10.30am – Conference call to London. Nike Fuel points: 1147. Speak less loudly.

12.pm – Early lunch with Stanley Lumax. Energy level – 1504. Already? That conference call must have been more frantic than I thought.

…And then I stopped checking until I got home…..

6.15pm – Home after subway ride. Kids bath. Energy level – 2611.

6.45pm – Story time. Kids get your pyjamas on already will you? Energy level – 2713. (Band removed during kids bath)

8pm – Unable to sync Nike Fuel with my iPhone via Bluetooth for the 20th time. Gave up.

10pm – Sneaked out to the bar. The ultimate test was about to begin. Nike Fuel points pre-pint: 3472

10.10pm – Proof about the positive effect of elbow-raising on personal fitness: Nike Fuel points post-pint: 3616

11.30pm – Home and time to sleep. Energy level – 4105. Smashed my goal on the first day….

So how did I do? Well, when I set it up with the Nike staffer I seem to remember that I was given a goal of 3,000 – which was supposed to be a pretty rigorous and energetic day. Sure, I took a 20 minute walk to work, but it was odd that a day of conference calls and distractions by kids (and three pints of IPA) put me well above my goal.

I was left feeling suspect about the quality of the tracking. The number of steps seemed appropriate when I walked but why did a pint of beer earn me 140 points? I also noticed that when I was in a taxi or on a subway ride the points went up too. I don’t think the technology is sophisticated enough to tell the difference between walking and driving on a bumpy New York City road, or between running and writing down notes on a pad.

There were also connectivity problems:  I was unable to sync the band to my phone via Bluetooth – and nothing seemed to fire up when I hooked the USB port to my computer. Really – do I have to go read the instructions?

And maybe the biggest take-away was that I found Nike’s view about health too simplistic. Nike Fuel is about movement but I know my health is connected with my diet and other variables like emotional well-being. I’ve checked out the specs online and there doesn’t seem to be any diet tracking. There seems to be a way to diarize an entry about a certain day somewhere in the cloud but what about collecting values of wellbeing on a chart?

There are so many sophisticated health tracking mobile tools available today and so the Nike Fuel seemed basic and naive. The Nike Fuel experience feels like what you got with a Fitbit device over 2 years ago. As it evolves, I think that the Nike Fuel mobile app will need to allow users to both photo-journal and statistically track ALL the other elements of health – otherwise it just becomes another pedometer.

With my diet tracking, I tried it for a week. I wore the band for a day. And now it’s off the wrist. Maybe the kids will find some joy in using it as a play thing….

 Nike Fuel

technology
Trending

Lyft Gives Free Rides To Those Who Have Had Too Much To Drink

Advertising
Syndicated Yesterday

Banned Books Week Urges People To Seek Out Controversial Works

Joining the annual celebration of the right to read, US author Jessica Herthel called for 'more information, more voices' to protect diversity

Augmented & Virtual Reality Yesterday

Outdoor Camp Presented In 360° VR By X Games Gold Medalist

The video features campers riding BMX trails, zip lining through the woods, and performing big-air jumps

Trending

Get PSFK's Related Report: Future of Automotive

See All
Travel Yesterday

Boeing Wants Passengers To Control Their In-Flight Experience Through Their Phones

The airline manufacturer is embracing automation through a new generation of mobile travel apps

Augmented / Virtual Reality Yesterday

VR Surgery Videos Offer Interactive Medical Education

Dutch startup MDLinking hopes to globalize communication between students and medical care professionals with virtual reality content

Related Expert

Mike McEwan

Mobile Payments

Culture Yesterday

Use Twitter To Learn A New Language

tDict is an app that uses the social media platform to help you search for words in local dialects

Mobile Yesterday

This Startup Wants To Digitize The Loose Coins In Your Pocket

CoinOut is a new app that lets you save your extra change from cash transactions as electronic funds

Advertising Yesterday

McDonald’s Is Accepting Trash As Currency In Exchange For Burgers

An initiative in Stockholm is trying to keep streets clean while satisfying hunger

PSFK LABS REPORT

Future Of Automotive
Scenarios Driving The Digital Transformation Of An Industry
NEW

PSFK Op-Ed september 23, 2016

Productivity Expert: The Magic Of The Five-Hour Workday

Stephan Aarstol, Founder of Tower Paddle Boards, explains why the modern notion of office hours needs to evolve

PSFK Labs september 22, 2016

The Future Of Work: Why Innovation Is Every Employee’s Job

PSFK Labs sits down with management at Johnson & Johnson to learn how the company comes up with their next ‘big idea’

Culture Yesterday

Google Is Using Virtual Paper Airplanes To Bring People Closer Together

The tech giant released an app that lets people throw their good wishes out into the world on the International Day of Peace

Advertising Yesterday

Get Paid For Traveling In San Francisco After Rush Hour

BART Perks rewards commuters who take early or late trains by giving them extra points to trade for money

Culture Yesterday

Artist Designs Covers For Books That Don’t Exist

Published by the fictional 'Specious Books,' the subversive works facilitate a conversation regarding the artistic integrity of graphic designers

Work Yesterday

Editorial Roundtable: The Arrival Of The People-First Workplace

Managed By Q, Soma, Workbar, Primary, AltSchool and thinkPARALLAX enumerate the reasons why companies need an employee-embracing workforce in order to exist

Food Yesterday

Bringing Food Innovation To America’s Crowded Milk Market

a2 Milk's Blake Waltrip, Chief Executive of the USA region, discusses how the distributor plans on bringing the popular drink for the dairy-sensitive to the States

PSFK LABS REPORT

Future Of Work
Cultivating The Next Generation Of Leaders
NEW

Financial Services Yesterday

Device Makes Digital Currency Feel Tangible

The concept gadget wants you to experience the highs and lows of spending money

Design & Architecture Yesterday

Why Building Better Offices Is The Key To Employee Engagement

Interaction Designer and Audio-visual Technologist at ESI Design illustrates the value in creating environments filled with surprise and delight

Augmented / Virtual Reality Yesterday

NBC Is Planning To Stream The Presidential Debates In Virtual Reality

Partnering with AltspaceVR, the broadcaster offers another way for Americans to engage with the election season

No search results found.