Piers Fawkes: Will Pay-By-Phone Be An Albatross For The Banking Industry?

Piers Fawkes: Will Pay-By-Phone Be An Albatross For The Banking Industry?

The rush to adopt the technology seems to mirror the electronic industry's desire to force 3D TV on viewers.

Piers Fawkes, PSFK
  • 3 march 2012

I’ve noticed that Europe is witnessing a lot of acitivity when it comes to large financial organizations getting into the pay-by-phone space. Recently PSFK reported the launch of the Pingit service from Barclays Bank. The service would allow customers to send money to each other easily using their phones.

Now Telefonica-owned O2 is planning to launch in the next three months a mobile money transfer app to rival Barclays’ service. This service would be offered to all banks to use. Visa is also planning a partnership with Vodafone. The new mobile wallet service to allow mobile phone customers to pay for goods and services using their handset. It will be available across all 30 countries that Vodafone operates in, starting with the UK, Germany, the Netherlands, Spain and Turkey. No doubt US financial corporations are watching and learning. Google is already testing its NFC service with a handful of retailers.

When it comes to pay-by-phone (and especially tap-to-pay) systems, there’s a lot of rapid deployment going on around the technology but I’m not too sure the customer is ready for. It reminds me of the move in the last few years by electronic companies to develop and market 3D TVs – maybe years before people seem ready to own one (and that the majority of programming will be in the required format).

Like the 3D TV space, at PSFK we haven’t seen much experimentation at the fringes around phone payments. While Sony and the others rushed to create their new TVs, we noticed that the hacking community were more interested in the interaction between the viewer and the set. Gesture and now sonic-interface have been explored by researchers, start-ups and other creative minds. Evidence of hacking of 3D TV technology by influential groups like new media artists is very hard to find. Microsoft Kinect‘s popularity and success is a because the natural user interface system followed years of gesture experimentation on the fringes. For Microsoft, it was the right time and the right product.

The experimentation at the intersection of NFC, RFID and mobile phones still seems to be very much at the storytelling and information gathering stages of the purchase path. At a tap of a phone, systems explain a product’s background or they tell you where you can get it. There are not a lot of examples of hacking culture exploring tap-to-pay payments.

For me, tap-to-pay also has a number of other challenges: it seems like a big win for the banks but I don’t quite see the huge advantage for consumers. The benefits are lopsided. It’s not like credit cards are heavy to carry or difficult to use. Also, cards offer choice at every payment occasion. The pay by phone movement seems to be about restricting your choice – and that could be where it hinders adoption.

From what I have read, it seems to be that when we will have the opportunity to pay-by-phone we will only be able to charge to one bank (the bank the phone maker, software or network is associated with). What happens if the payment is a business expense or something that should go to you and your partner’s joint account? Do banks, networks and handset makers expect us to navigate a menu of options on our phone to find the right card? Surely just picking the right piece of plastic from your wallet would be quicker and simpler? Oh, it is.

Maybe banks and phone companies should not run away the user-friendly card format but look at the digital connection between them. Maybe cards cannot be used outside 5 feet of their owner’s phone. Maybe phones get pinged with loyalty point balances and other bonuses upon a swipe. Retailers and finance companies need to look at current behavior and adapt around it, rather than expect people to change because of their technology.


Get A Better Idea Of How You Are Wasting Your Time

Syndicated Today

What Could The Highway Of The Future Look Like?

As technology for automated vehicles improves, there’s a sharper focus on building a ‘smarter’ infrastructure where they can thrive

Design Today

Plastic Wind Trees Are Bringing Sustainable Power To Residential Homes

These French-made turbines are offering a small, aesthetically pleasing approach to affordable personal energy


Get PSFK's Latest Report: Future of Retail: Technology Primer

See All
Home Today

Dyson’s Wi-Fi Connected Fan Purifies, Cools & Heats The Air

The new luxury home appliance aims to be an all-in-one device for the connected home

Education Today

Bringing Virtual Reality And Telepresence Robotics To E-Learning

This Learning Management System is embracing new technologies to reallocate teaching resources to where they should be going


Abigail Posner

Digital Strategy, Emotion and Technology

Advertising Today

Brewing Company Turns Car Emissions Into Ink

Tiger Beer has created a sustainable process to transform air pollution into supplies for street art

Design Today

Space-Saving Sofa Has Extra Furniture Hidden Inside

Living in an apartment with limited space? This three-in-one bed transforms based on your needs

Culture Today

Browser Extension Blocks Any Pages That Make You Unhappy

The software can detect your facial movements and prevent content that brings up negative emotions


Future Of Work
Cultivating The Next Generation Of Leaders

PSFK Op-Ed august 25, 2016

Retail Expert: What Sustainability Means To The Millennial Generation

Jo Godden, Founder of RubyMoon, discusses how brands can limit their environmental impact worldwide

PSFK Labs august 25, 2016

PSFK’s Workplace Vision: How The Nurturing Of Seeds Will Come To Define The Onboarding Process

Our Future of Work vision is a service that allows companies to assemble and deliver welcome packets that are uniquely focused on the concept of growth

Automotive Today

Reserve Your Parking Spot Before You Even Get Behind The Wheel

A new Ford app allows drivers to select and arrange for a space in a garage to be available at the end of their journey, so they can travel worry-free

Work Today

PSFK’s Workplace Vision: The Desk Is Becoming An Ecosystem Of Satellite Workstations

Our Future of Work vision is an app that frees employees from the tyranny of a static desk

Work Today

Editorial Roundtable: What A People-First Workplace Must Prioritize First

Managed By Q, Soma, Workbar, Primary, AltSchool and thinkPARALLAX on why employee fulfillment is a journey and not a destination

Food Today

A Tiny Amount Of This Powder Could Block All The Bitterness In Food

A new substance made from mushrooms can bond with taste receptors on your tongue to overcome unpleasant flavors

Asia Today

Whimsical Dental Clinic Design Aims To Calm Patient Fears

Cheerful colors and a nod to the comforts of home are design elements tactfully aimed to help people relax


Rio Olympics
Innovation Coverage From The Rio Games

Mobile Today

Messenger Service Only Delivers You Updates Three Times A Day

Formal is a new app designed to help people ignore the constant stream of texts from their phone and focus on what's in front of them

Design Today

Movable Vacation House Constructed Using Concrete Boxes

The 4,000 square foot building is made up of modular frames so it can be relocated if needed due to coastline erosion

No search results found.