Designing A Scalable Mass Transit Solution For 21st Century Cities [PSFK CONFERENCE SF]

Designing A Scalable Mass Transit Solution For 21st Century Cities [PSFK CONFERENCE SF]

PSFK talks to frog's Principal Designer about an aerial public transportation solution that costs a fraction of the price of other public transportation options to implement.

Timothy Ryan, PSFK Labs
  • 28 october 2012

PSFK is excited to welcome Michael McDaniel as a speaker at PSFK CONFERENCE SAN FRANCISCO. Michael is a Principal Designer at frog, the global design and innovation firm. frog works with the world’s leading companies to design, engineer, and bring to market meaningful products and services. On November 1st, Michael will discuss developing an aerial mass-transit solution that is scalable for 21st century cities.

Can you introduce us to the Wire? What was the need?

The Wire is a mass transit solution geared specifically for the city of Austin, Texas. The interdisciplinary team behind the Wire concept is based in frog’s Austin studio. As local residents, we saw an absolute need for a valid mass transit solution in our fast-growing and complex city.

Austin needs a mass transit system that doesn’t compete for the same real estate as everything else. It needs to go above, not through, the city’s existing infrastructure.” We began to look at ski lifts because they’re cheap and they can be implemented very quickly. We asked the question: “Why haven’t ski lifts or cable‑powered transit been considered as a viable solution for mass transit in a place like Austin?”

Rather than reinvent the wheel, we decided to approach the city’s mass transit problem from a completely different perspective.

What are the obstacles to implementing mass transit solutions?

With the exception of the Northeast, most Americans prefer the freedom and mobility of automobiles. People dislike being dependent on a schedule. Furthermore, most mass transit systems are incredibly expensive to implement, which is a non-starter for cash-strapped cities.

Light rail, on average, costs $50 million per mile to implement. A subway costs about $150‑300 million per mile to actually dig. The materials and manpower alone are expensive, but the additional cost comes from competing for the same real estate as buildings, cars, and roads. By comparison, it costs rough $1-3 million dollars per mile to expand a freeway by one line. So most cities opt for the interim solution of freeway expansion, even when a mass transit solution may better suit the long-term needs of the city.

How did you begin the process of designing a solution?

We asked, “Is there a way that we can get something that actually appeals to the American culture of wanting freedom and flexibility that’s economically viable to actually put in?”

Most of mass transit, especially for cities in the Western US, is over 100 years old and runs on an open grid structure. These cities aren’t geographically confined, so there’s no financial incentive to build mass transit, and if you look at the cost of rails, it’s just exorbitantly expensive.

After our research, we found that a gondola actually seemed like a valid solution. When you start thinking about gondolas, overhead cable‑powered transit, it’s extremely cheap to put in, per mile. You can typically install it for under $10 million dollars per mile.

It gets to be really fun, as a designer, when you start thinking about architectural principles like denial and reward. You can design processions or entrances into cities, where you pop up and you have these grand vistas of the skyline, or a beautiful portion of the city, and then you can literally drop down and skim the grass and skirt right through a park or down a waterway. You have this variance in elevation, so it can offer you a scenic view, which no other form of mass transit can.

It became even more powerful, because if you think about ski lifts, they’re constantly in motion. They’re not trains, so if you intersperse them properly, you can have the cars coming through at one-minute intervals, and if the system is always running, you’re not tethered to a schedule. Now you have the freedom and flexibility similar to that of a car.

Once we had the concept, we began to ask, “How could we actually implement this thing, or make it real? What would be the economic incentives for the city?” We started looking at the necessary real‑world conditions to make it happen.

Can you talk a little more about the cultural implications?

In Austin we had a light rail system voted down on ballot measures strictly because the businesses didn’t want to be disrupted for five years. Beyond the pure installation and infrastructure costs of implementing the mass transit system, you also have to think about the economic impact on local businesses. The construction can obstruct foot and automotive traffic to those businesses for as long as three to five years. Even if a mass transit system is a boon for them later, most business owners will not want to endure three to five years of reduced revenue.

We designed The Wire to align with the cultural context in the U.S., where people want freedom and mobility. When you start looking at the cost of the infrastructure, ski lifts are designed to be installed between ski seasons and are engineered to be implemented quickly.

The Wire can be built without disrupting local businesses, which eliminates significant upfront cost and ensures community buy-in.

What are the social benefits of connecting communities together in this way?

Threading the community together with a transit system like the Wire offers a multitude of economic benefits.

Austin is a very heavy bike town. Everybody here likes to put on spandex and get out in the middle of traffic and think that they’re in the Tour de France. It actually causes a host of problems common to other cities, in which you have people using disparate modes of transit and competing for the same real estate. What about eliminating the competition by coordinating transit? The advantage of the Wire is that it ties different modes of transit together. Instead of ripping up infrastructure to create new bike lanes, encourage cyclists to use the Wire to leapfrog from spot to spot. They can actually roll their bikes onto the gondolas, hop over a couple of traffic spots in the city without any fear of mortal danger, and continue on their way.

Combining modes of transit creates new opportunities to augment the travel experience altogether. For example, you could pay more per month to the transit authority, and actually have access to Amsterdam style city bikes, rental cars, or services like Car2go simultaneously. By integrating them under one, easy‑to‑use fare system, you create a system that is a lot more powerful and flexible.

The key is not to ask people to change their behavior, but to design the system to adapt to their needs.

Thanks Michael!

frog design//@mcdanyel

Please join us on November 1st to hear how Michael is developing scalable, aerial mass-transit solutions for 21st century cities at PSFK CONFERENCE SAN FRANCISCO.


Japanese Face Wash Creates A Perfect Rose Every Time

Arts & Culture
Work Today

PSFK’s Workplace Vision: The Desk Is Transformed Into Dynamic System Of Satellite Workstations

Our Future of Work vision is an app that frees employees from the tyranny of a static desk

Work Today

Editorial Roundtable: What A People-First Workplace Must Prioritize First

Managed By Q, Soma, Workbar, Primary, AltSchool and thinkPARALLAX on why employee fulfillment is a journey and not a destination


Get PSFK's Latest Report: Innovation Debrief: Boston

See All
Food Today

A Tiny Amount Of This Powder Could Block All The Bitterness In Food

A new substance made from mushrooms can bond with taste receptors on your tongue to overcome unpleasant flavors

Asia Today

Whimsical Dental Clinic Design Aims To Calm Patient Fears

Cheerful colors and a nod to the comforts of home are design elements tactfully aimed to help people relax

Mobile Today

Messenger Service Only Delivers You Updates Three Times A Day

Formal is a new app designed to help people ignore the constant stream of texts from their phone and focus on what's in front of them

Design Today

Movable Vacation House Constructed Using Concrete Boxes

The 4,000 square foot building is made up of modular frames so it can be relocated if needed due to coastline erosion

Design Today

Redesigned Electric Fan Collapses For Easy Storage

Conbox can be kept in pieces and packed away when not in use


Future Of Work
Cultivating The Next Generation Of Leaders

PSFK Op-Ed august 24, 2016

Why Building Better Offices Is The Key To Employee Engagement

Interaction Designer and Audio-visual Technologist at ESI Design illustrates the value in creating environments filled with surprise and delight

PSFK Labs august 25, 2016

PSFK’s Workplace Vision: How The Nurturing Of Seeds Will Come To Define The Onboarding Process

Our Future of Work vision is a service that allows companies to assemble and deliver welcome packets that are uniquely focused on the concept of growth

Ai Today

LawyerBot Is Now Helping Homeless People Qualify For Government Housing

This robot helps people get out of parking tickets and provides free legal advice to those in need

Travel Today

This Head Hammock Promises The Best Sleep You’ll Ever Get While Traveling

NodPod holds your neck and back perpendicular, hopefully putting an end to sleepless and uncomfortable journeys

Mobile august 26, 2016

Get A Better Idea Of How You Are Wasting Your Time

The TouchTime app is trying to revolutionize personal task management by providing detailed insight on how to be more efficient

Culture august 26, 2016

London Telephone Box Repurposed As A Tiny Mobile Repair Shop

Tools and supplies to replace broken screens or damage are neatly stowed away in these micro-workrooms

Design august 26, 2016

Conceptual Sportswear Created Out Of Futuristic Condom Material

A Dutch fashion designer is experimenting with new methods and fabrics to make high performance clothing


Rio Olympics
Innovation Coverage From The Rio Games

Fashion august 26, 2016

Fashionable Tassel Will Ensure You Never Lose Your Valuables Again

The device is fashion meets connected tech, that will help you keep track of your belongings at all times

Syndicated august 26, 2016

Would You Wear Wool Shoes To Save The Environment?

As demand for wool shoes grows, a number of US footwear brands are heading directly to the source: the sheep pastures of New Zealand

No search results found.