Rider Research Reveals Ideal Subway Car Design

Rider Research Reveals Ideal Subway Car Design

Researchers suggest reevaluation of the layout of NYC trains based on the behaviors of riders.

Alan Khanukaev
  • 22 april 2013

Over the past 50 years or so, seating layouts on trains of the New York City subway system have not changed all that much. According to a recently released preliminary report compiled by the Transportation Research Board, there are several redesigns that could potentially be implemented in order to maximize space and improve the flow of riders getting on and off the train.

Over the course of three weeks, researchers collected data while riding in over 60 different subway cars. They observed a variety of behaviors with a specific focus on when and where riders chose to sit vs. stand, for how long, and how they behaved toward one another. They noted areas of congestion as well as areas of unutilized space and how all of these variables shifted as the train fills or empties. The researchers specifically focused on off-peak times of the day noting that rush hour completely changes the dynamic because riders have much fewer options regarding sitting and standing.

Conducted from February 21 to March 13 of 2012, many of the study’s findings should come as no surprise to NYC Straphangers. From their observations the authors note that, overall, riders prefer to stand near the doors even when there’s more space towards the middle of the car, they prefer vertical poles over horizontal bars, and they generally tend to avoid the middle seat, which is likely part of a larger overarching preference of not wanting to be right next to other riders. In fact, this tendency is so pronounced that, according to the TRB, “90% seat utilization is only achieved at 120% load factor.” In other words, as a train starts filling up, riders are less likely to occupy a seat, opting instead for a modicum of personal space. Therefore a car has to be 20% overcapacity in order for 90% of the seats to be occupied.

Another fascinating discovery the authors point out touches on Game Theory and has to do with seat strategy. They note that:

Customers do change seats as seats become available due to passengers disembarking, but seat change maneuvers incur utility costs (movement effort, and risk of desired seat becoming occupied mid-maneuver); to find desirable seats often requires customers to relinquish their current less-desirable seats in advance of busy stops, and position themselves strategically close to where seat-turnover seem likely.

Proposed Subway Layout

From their observations and anectdotal evidence, the researchers, Aaron Berkovich, Alex Lu, Brian Levine, and Alla V. Reddy, compiled several options for a possible redesign of NYC Subway cars. Among these are:

  • Asymmetrical door placement. Meaning that the doors on one side should not directly face the doors on the other side.
  • Avoid designing middle seats. If longer benches are necessary, partition and poles can be used to break up the distance.
  • Installing poles between seating areas rather than between doors.
  • Installing poles or partitions in the middle of bench seats, rather than by doors. These partitions will also have the added benefits of discouraging people from lying down.
  • Removing seats from the middle of the car, to accommodate short distance riders, and adding seats to the ends of the car to accommodate longer distance riders.

It is important to note that these suggestions are based on a purely observational study, and would ideally require further experimentation to determine just how effective these redesigns would be. However, it will be interesting to see what the MTA makes of these preliminary results and if they decide to move forward with additional research.

TRB Report

Image Credit: Daniel Schwen


Transformable Table Maximizes Utility In Small Spaces

Design & Architecture
Syndicated Yesterday

How Fashion Became All About Fonts

Why a new wave of designs have put typography front and center on your clothing

Retail Yesterday

GM And Audi Are Experimenting With Car Rentals In SF

The automakers are trying something new to capture the segment of urban dwellers who don't want to own a car


Get PSFK's Related Report: Future of Automotive

See All
Travel Yesterday

This Vertical Forest Hotel Will Improve The Air Around It

An architectural firm is creating a lush mountain lodging in China with so much greenery that it will actually clean the atmosphere

Related Expert

Mario Schlosser

Health Insurance, Data, Technology

Europe Yesterday

This Company Believes Insects Can Provide Biofuel To Power Our Future

A Polish group is testing out a new factory concept that can provide a source of renewable energy, and even serve space missions

Technology Yesterday

Music Venue Caters To Virtual Reality Events

Boiler Room has launched the first VR hub for content creators to capture special footage for the masses

Gaming & Play Yesterday

Automated Chessboard Lets You Play Against Anyone In The World

Square Off is an AI-powered board that can move the pieces on its own


Future Of Automotive
Scenarios Driving The Digital Transformation Of An Industry

PSFK Op-Ed Yesterday

Creative Leadership Expert: Experiencing A Seismic Shift From Brand Loyalty To Interface Loyalty

Marc Shillum, founder of Chief Creative Office, explains why product designers must rethink the way they capture consumer attention

PSFK Labs october 25, 2016

The Keys For Exceptional Performance On And Off The Field

PSFK Labs' new report highlights five important insights for businesses to perform better than the competition

Technology Yesterday

Contraband Recorder Helps Those In Need Capture Captive Conversations

Designer Marianna Mezhibovkaya created the device to help prison inmates capture crucial evidence of abuse

Advertising Yesterday

A Compelling Brand Purpose Is Never Born In The Boardroom

Strategist and Designer Anna-Rae Morris shares why she believes all brands exist for a reason, and how Snapchat has upended our behavior

Fitness & Sport Yesterday

Editorial Roundtable: The Xs And Os Of Performance-Enhanced Sports

WHOOP, ShotTracker, Rithmio, PlaySight, STYR Labs, EverybodyFights and Lift / Next Level Floats explain that we're only at the iceberg's tip of performance enhancement

Retail Yesterday

Kodak’s Smartphone Is Inspired By A Retro Camera

Ektra is an Android phone with a powerful lens aimed at photographers

Sustainability Yesterday

Modern Home Created Entirely Out Of Modular Shipping Crates

A project in Ecuador used the ubiquitous material to design a spacious and industrial-chic house

Retail Yesterday

Retail Concept Offers Food Hall Inspired Space For Online Brands

The store will offer a lower cost way for internet entrepreneurs to try physical retailing

Advertising Yesterday

Disney Retells Beauty And The Beast On Snapchat

In a partnership with LACMA, the entertainment platform drew from over 130,000 works in the museum's collection

No search results found.