Michael Wolff: Why Paywalls Won’t Solve Newspapers’ Larger Issues

Michael Wolff: Why Paywalls Won’t Solve Newspapers’ Larger Issues

Not even the smartest metered model can make up for meagre digital ad revenues and a failure to recruit younger readers.

Michael Wolff, Guardian
  • 2 april 2013

Powered by
This article titled “This tipping-point for paywalls does not fix newspapers’ larger crisis” was written by Michael Wolff, for on Monday 1st April 2013 14.30 UTC

To the surprise of many digital evangelizers and old-media doubters, newspaper paywalls turn out to work. Sort of.

The Washington Post and the Daily Telegraph in London are the latest to announce their pay plan, so that, in the foreseeable future, most rather than a select few papers will have implemented some kind of subscription or metered fare.

The New York Times deserves credit for the breakthrough: it created a model that is “porous” enough that if you don’t want to pay, you don’t have to, and if you read the Times regularly enough and don’t care about not paying, you will. This has added a significant new revenue stream, while yet preserving the Times’ online advertising income (anemic though that is).

The Times’ success turns on its ear the old notion of news economics: that there is enormous price sensitivity among news consumers and that small rises in price mean big circulation drops. (Conversely, as Rupert Murdoch has frequently shown, small drops in cost have meant big circulation rises.) The Times model leads the way to demonstrating, as the news analyst Ken Doctor has observed, a much different conclusion: loyal newspaper readers have minimal price sensitivity, if any at all. This is true for both online and offline subscription costs. Or, put another way, old people will pay anything to maintain their newspaper habit.

Or, put another way still, the paywall, other than providing a bit more time to wrestle with the underlining problems of newspapers, does not solve any of them.

Even with this new class of free-spending readers, the economic problems remain exactly the same:

• An extraordinary indifference, if not utter lack of interest, on the part of younger people to news brands and to news habits, a development that established news organizations have been unable to address, stall, or even fathom.

• Dramatic abandonment of the medium by traditional advertisers, such that, since 2007, newspapers, according to industry monitor group Outsell, have seen more than a 40% decline in overall income, the overwhelming amount of that drop due to lost ad revenues.

• A digital advertising environment on the web – one even more pronounced in mobile – that relentlessly increases the amount of advertising space available and lowers the value of all space overall.

And then there’s the competition.

There is an aggressive new news business, including, but hardly limited to, the Huffington Post, the Drudge Report, Business Insider, Buzzfeed, Politico, Yahoo News, and Google News, built on the idea of producing full service news products with significantly fewer resources and at significantly less cost than traditional news organizations – largely, by recycling free digital news feeds.

And now, the next generation of free news may have begun with Yahoo’s recent acquisition of Summly, an automatic news summarizer and aggregator. Thus the most pronounced and successful trend in online news is not adding paywalls, but providing more news with significantly fewer people.

Paywalls, in other words, don’t alter the existential drama.

Without a dramatic turnaround in advertising income, there are only two strategies – neither mutually exclusive – for the continued existence of newspapers, in digital or any other form:

• Having established the paywall model, the goal, in a race against time, is to extend it to a greater and greater part of the user base. Like the paywall itself, this is unchartered territory. Rupert Murdoch’s more absolute paywalls having worked significantly less well than the New York Times’ porous wall. The Times, however, counting on its brand power and on the gradual change in consumer behavior, is trying to up the ante, recently cutting its free take from 20 to ten articles.

• Re-orient the cost basis of the business, still largely modeled on advertising income, to the much smaller subscription revenue base. That is, fire a lot of people.

This is, actually, good news, if not necessarily for shareholders or for many employees. Some newspapers can continue to exist, albeit as vastly smaller and less profitable businesses.

There is, too, the inverse strategy: no paywall. If the Times establishes one model of limited success, the Daily Mail establishes the opposite model of limited success. In essence, the Mail has played an entirely un-newspaper game, much less trying hold onto and finance what has worked offline, and much more trying to focus on what works online. Using large amounts of aggregation, and focusing relentlessly on celebrities, with search engine and social media strategies, it has, in fact, outdone almost all its native online competitors in the quest for traffic and wholly trounced every other newspaper.

Still, given the ever-dropping digital advertising rates, even the Mail, with its traffic gold mine, can’t recreate its offline scale.

Curiously, it seems plausible to argue that, given the loyalty of many readers and the digital undermining of advertising income, many newspapers might have fared better having not become digital products. Certainly, all would have fared better if none had.

But the world is as it is. © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010

Published via the Guardian News Feed plugin for WordPress.


Tokyo Concept Store Disguised As A Parking Garage

Automotive Today

Uber Now Lets Commuters Pay With Pretax Dollars

The prepaid cards are a partnership with WageWorks, letting uberPool users save up to 40% on their trip

Home Today

Philips Hue Adds Motion Sensor To Control Lights Automatically

The wireless device lets users interact with their environment without needing to press a switch


Get PSFK's Latest Report: Future of Retail: Technology Primer

See All
Brand Development Today

The 10 Steps To Discover, Hire, Develop Your Next Leader

PSFK's Future of Work report outlines key steps in the employee development path to empower next-gen leaders

Home Today

Beacon Device Takes The Pain Out Of Navigating A New Airbnb

Ping provides new guests with a guided tour of the house or apartment through a simple tap of their phone

Arts & Culture Today

Shelf Makes Its Contents Appear To Hover In Midair

The design uses metal tubes to create an optical illusion when viewed from the front

Fashion Today

Declutter And Recycle All Of Your Unwanted Stuff

A new app will help catalogue your possessions and give them away as donations when you no longer want them

Fitness / Sport Today

This Health App Will Pay You For Every Step You Take

Sweatcoin records your fitness activities and donates to charity based on exercise


Future Of Work
Cultivating The Next Generation Of Leaders

PSFK Op-Ed august 24, 2016

Why Building Better Offices Is The Key To Employee Engagement

Interaction Designer and Audio-visual Technologist at ESI Design illustrates the value in creating environments filled with surprise and delight

PSFK Labs Today

PSFK’s Workplace Vision: Leave The Busywork To The Bots

Our Future of Work vision is an artificially intelligent helper that frees workers from the administrative to-dos that have dogged them for too long

Technology Today

How Motion Tracking Is Finding Its Way Into Design Craftsmanship

Expanding on traditional modeling, a Toronto-based designer is experimenting with how physical gestures can generate functional 3D topographies

Work Yesterday

Amazon Is Experimenting With A 30-Hour Work Week

The online retailer is launching a pilot program that will allow a technical team to work with a considerably shortened schedule

Fitness / Sport Yesterday

How The Rio Olympics Stood For More Than Just Games

PSFK rounds out the Rio Games with our picks for the finest moments beyond sports

Retail Yesterday

Mobile Travel App Embraces Cognitive Computing

The Orlando Tourism Board is looking to IBM Watson to provide personalized local recommendations for visitors

Design Yesterday

Kate Spade’s New Fitness Trackers Push Wearable Tech Into High Fashion

The retailer joins other designers in bringing tech-assisted lifestyles to the luxury clothing market


Rio Olympics
Innovation Coverage From The Rio Games

Automotive Yesterday

Bike-Friendly Apartment Building For Swedish Cyclists

A residential space is being designed for commuters to easily transport goods

Advertising Yesterday

Nike Takes Over An Entire City Block With A Giant Running Track

The Unlimited Stadium is shaped like a 100-meter sole print of the brand's LunarEpic sneaker

Gaming Yesterday

Fortune Cookie Service Brings Bad News To Your Doorstep

To promote their new delivery service Blackbox, the creators of Cards Against Humanity are delivering unfortunate messages in an edible form

No search results found.