Crowd Planning Brings Collaboration Into Urban Design [My Ideal City]

Crowd Planning Brings Collaboration Into Urban Design [My Ideal City]

PSFK chats with John Geraci of DIYCity, about how crowd planning is impacting city development.

  • 26 may 2013

As part of our series looking at the future of cities, PSFK reached out to experts to get their take on key trends we’ve identified that are currently affecting urban environments. John Geraci is the founder of DIYCity, a site where people from all over the world think about, talk about, and ultimately build tools for making their cities work better with web technologies. He spoke with about how crowd planned solutions are lowering the barriers to participation and empowering citizens to design their own communities.

Why is it important that citizens play an integral part in planning their cities?

A city’s residents are the only ones who really get the problems and challenges of cities at the first person level.  They’re ‘the man on the ground’, the forward ops. If you have cities being planned and run without residents’ first-person input, you end up with cities designed by planners that look great as a picture on a placemat but that don’t necessarily work well for individuals.

And that was fine before the Internet came along – maybe it was the best we could do.  Now luckily we’ve got all of these tools for collaboration that allow us to add that ‘man (or woman) on the ground’ voice into the mix.  So there’s no excuse not to do it.

How do you see the trend of crowd planning developing over time?

Well something that projects like Neighborland are going to have to grapple with in order to really be impacting is how to sustain themselves.  Who is going to pay for it day in and day out, for the next ten years?  That’s going to have a big impact over how this trend plays out, because we’ve seen so many examples now of sites like this with great intentions, which ultimately fade away because there isn’t enough money to pay for them and the creators run themselves ragged trying to keep it going.

Maybe this kind of site plus crowdfunding, is the magic combination to create a lasting service for communities.

The other challenge for these kinds of sites/ideas is how to get and sustain critical mass and visibility when you’re operating at a local level.  That’s something that every local community site has to grapple with, and it can be really daunting.  Critical mass is hard enough to get at a global level – when you split that up into a bunch of little localities, it becomes downright grueling.

So those two things, sustainability plus visibility, will I think drive what emerges as a future model for these sorts of ideas.  Whatever the model is, it will have to nail those two things in order to survive and have real impact.

A colleague of mine at faberNovel is working on a documentary on different communities’ efforts at collaboration for civic improvement, called Collaborative Cities.  It’s sort of a real-time, evolving snapshot of all of these impulses.  Great and definitely worth checking out here:

What advantages do crowd-led methods of urban planning have over more traditional practices?

I don’t see it as ‘crowd-led methods over traditional practices’, I see it as adding the crowd-led methods to the existing practices to make them more participatory while also lowering their costs.  There is definitely huge potential for this to create new channels for discussion and information exchange, to influence how decisions and allocations get made, and to do this at scale.  It’s still incredibly early in the development of these kinds of ideas, and it will evolve over time, in bits and pieces and with lots of failures along the way.

Generally speaking, does technology create more opportunities for civic engagement within cities?

Technology (web technology) definitely creates more opportunities for civic engagement.  But it’s still an open question as to what the best way to harness that is and make it lasting.  Ideally you want to have a great feedback loop going between planners, city government, and residents.  When you have that, the city becomes like a living body perfectly in tune with itself.  And web technology has the potential to provide that better than anything else.

What three things would you include in your perfect city?

Okay I’m going to give you a totally honest answer here and it has nothing to do with tech:

1) Parks, trees and green spaces within easy walking distance of wherever you live.  A river you could actually swim in would be great too, wouldn’t it?

2) Many places to run into friends and get into conversations with strangers.  Social serendipity counts for so much in cities, IMO.

3) The best opportunities for interesting work in the world.  No explanation needed.

DIY City


Q: What improvements should the community come together to decide about your neighborhood?

Submit your answer now at the MyIdealCity site – or tweet your suggestion using #MyIdealCity and #CitizenSourced


Over the next 6 months, PSFK and a team of experts imagining the future of a city will be asking you what you envision as ‘My Ideal City’. Tweet us your ideas using the hashtag of the week and view all the submissions at the MyIdealCity site.


How Indiegogo Is Becoming An Adult Product Destination

Home september 23, 2016

Watch This Fire Pit Dance Along To Your Favorite Song

Music City Fire is a system that is designed to flicker in time to ambient music

Automotive september 23, 2016

Slick GPS Navigator Gives Directions To Moped Riders

This small, round device attaches to a sideview mirror to display maps for safer traveling


Get PSFK's Related Report: Future of Automotive

See All
Home september 23, 2016

A Clock That Beautifully Manages Your Information Overload

The wall-mounted timekeeper is made to help people maintain focus and stay up to date with their appointments

Arts & Culture september 23, 2016

Performance Piece Blends Dancers Into Folds Of Light

The work provides commentary on the increasing connection between programmed and analog dimensions

Related Expert

Bonnie Knutson

Hospitality & Marketing

Design & Architecture september 23, 2016

Design Firm Adapts Childhood Homes For Unemployed Young Adults

The studio has unveiled three prototypes of transformed living spaces for people forced to move back in with their families

Health september 23, 2016

These Chocolate Squares Claim To Reverse The Aging Process

A group of researchers from Cambridge University have developed a candy bar that promises to give you a youthful glow

Cities september 23, 2016

Food-Producing Architecture Competition Seeks To Better Feed Cities

A design challenge in Copenhagen highlights the need and beauty of urban farming


Future Of Automotive
Scenarios Driving The Digital Transformation Of An Industry

PSFK Op-Ed september 21, 2016

Everything I Know About Leadership I Learned Teaching 7th Grade Math

Bree Groff, Managing Director at NOBL NYC, shares her secrets for knowing your employees and enabling a team

PSFK Labs september 22, 2016

The Future Of Work: Why Innovation Is Every Employee’s Job

PSFK Labs sits down with management at Johnson & Johnson to learn how the company comes up with their next ‘big idea’

Health september 23, 2016

Wearable Monitors Sun Exposure To Prevent Sunburn

The clip monitors UV rays to make sure you're not receiving too much sunlight

Op-Ed september 23, 2016

Productivity Expert: The Magic Of The Five-Hour Workday

Stephan Aarstol, Founder of Tower Paddle Boards, explains why the modern notion of office hours needs to evolve

Culture september 23, 2016

This Exhibition’s Crowning Jewel Is An 18k Gold-Plated Toilet

The piece, titled 'America,' is meant to raise questions about the country's wealth inequality

Culture september 23, 2016

Match Up With Dates On Tinder Based On Your Music Preferences

A new partnership with Spotify lets people pair up based on shared tastes in artists

Entertainment september 23, 2016

Capture, Cut Up, And Configure Your World In 360 Degrees

To meet a booming 360 and VR video-capturing industry, a multimedia software company bolstered its media editing suite for 360-video creation


Future Of Work
Cultivating The Next Generation Of Leaders

Advertising september 23, 2016

These Trucks Drove Around In Circles For 24 Hours To Keep Time

The giant ticking clock was created by 14 Scania vehicles in a deserted airfield

Advertising september 23, 2016

Buy Movie Tickets Directly From Your Facebook Profile

The new feature is part of a campaign from Fandango to further imbed social media into the ticket vendor's digital presence

Asia september 23, 2016

Co-Working Space Brings The Calming Atmosphere Of Nature Indoors

An architectural firm in China has designed a new type of shared office that prioritizes the natural environment

No search results found.