menu

Johnnie Moore: Why Meetings Are Often Ineffective

Johnnie Moore: Why Meetings Are Often Ineffective
Advertising

Author tells us why 'action theater' is hindering truly productive work chats with colleagues, and what we can do to help.

Johnnie Moore
  • 13 october 2013

Security guru Bruce Schneier derides as “security theater” much of the rigmarole we experience at airports. Bureaucratic routine gives the impression of adding to safety, but it often gets in the way of the flexibility and alertness needed.

I have long felt that organisations have an equivalent blind spot, not at airports but in everyday meetings. I call it “action theater” — we go through a series of rituals apparently to ensure we have action, but are in fact deluding ourselves, and draining the energy of just about everyone involved.

Avoiding “action theatre”

I’m sure you’ve been there. You’re sitting in a meeting. Discussions have been going for some time. And someone — maybe it’s you — says something like, “Well, all this talk is all very well, but it’s meaningless unless we agree on some actions.”

And who could disagree with that? Usually, a number of people murmur agreement as if this is some really profound or exciting insight.

As someone who facilitates a lot of meetings, another familiar variation on this theme  happens a lot at lunchtime during one-day events. Someone comes up to me and says they have been talking to “some people” who are “getting concerned that there isn’t going to be any action.”

Personally, I’m pretty wary of second-hand complaints, so I usually ask this guy if there is any particular action he or she is hoping to see. Nine times out ten, they look a bit panicked and admit that there isn’t. Which may be true. Or it may just be that there is but they don’t want to take responsibility for it.

It seems as though someone cares about action, but really, it’s just theater.

Just urging action is like entering a room, rolling your eyes, telling everyone how untidy it is (by which you really mean, how untidy they are), and then leaving without picking up any litter.

Instead of falling into this trap, take the risk of being clearer about what you want or what you feel. And get in the habit of challenging those who demand “action” to be more specific. (By the way, the same goes for other popular management abstractions like “change” and “innovation”.)

Cancel commitment ceremonies

The risk of action theater tends to rise the longer meetings continue. That’s often to do with having something to present to powers-that-be outside the room, to prove that the event hasn’t just been a talking-shop. And it certainly conforms to a neat and tidy notion of having meetings that follow a linear path ending in certainty and completion.

The trouble is, in the real world, these action planning sessions are often deadly and fake. They assume the following:

  • That action is what is needed now, as opposed to, say, further reflection
  • That the people in the room are uniquely empowered to act, when frequently they aren’t
  • That everyone’s nicely aligned and all are agreed on what should happen
  • That everyone has been able to assimilate a whole lot of new information, make sense of it, and can now make a decision

Often, people will go along with these commitment ceremonies not because they’re wildly enthused. Really, their commitment translates as, No, I won’t do this, but I’m saying yes because it’s 5 o’clock and I want to go home. We all know what’s agreed here may have only a passing resemblance to what will actually happen in the real world, anyway.”

You end up with pseudo-agreements that just tick boxes for productivity.

Instead of bullying people into action, try to get them to be clear on the point they have actually reached in a way that means everyone speaks and is heard. You might have a round where everyone is allowed a chance to check in, perhaps responding to a very open question that lets them choose to report what they’ve learnt, what they’re concerned about, and what they see happening next without a sense that only “action” is to be the focus.

What often happens is the groups get a few surprises in this process, realising that a lot has been going on for people and that people in the room are often responding in quite different ways: some are reflective, some inspired, and some anxious. Quite often, it turns out the people have already agreed actions anyway, and these sound much more convincing than those you get from an commitment ritual.

It’s a more human and believable way to end a meeting. It acknowledges the complexity and richness of people’s experience instead of squashing it into boxes. It may not look so tidy or fit a spreadsheet, but it feels more real.

Move, move, move

And instead of all this pretend action, maybe what you need is some real, genuine, physical activity. It seems that in most organisations, sitting still and pontificating is a badge of status. I think this creates really boring meetings and a terrible quality of thought.

Baba Shiv of Stanford University conducted an experiment, reported here. Students were put into two groups. Both had to memorise a number and were then sent to another room for refreshment. In that room was a choice of healthy fruit or less healthy cake. One group only had to remember a two-digit number. The other had to cope with seven digits. Those with the seven-digit task were significantly more likely to opt for cake than fruit.

That’s because even a small amount of extra mental activity degrades the operation of our pre-frontal cortex, and with it, our reasoning and willpower.

In too many meetings we sit for too long, arguing with what we think is great cleverness when in fact our rational brain is already worn out and running on empty.

We need to move about and do things, not simply sit and talk. We’re not meant to sit still for long. Apart from the obvious health risks of sitting for too long, if our bodies are stuck, our minds are likely to be stuck too. Movement gives a different perspective. Movement stimulates different parts of your brain.

The human brain evolved under conditions of almost constant motion. From this, one might predict that the optimal environment for processing information would include motion. That is exactly what one finds. Indeed, the best business meeting would have everyone walking at about 1.8 miles per hour.” — John Medina, Brain Rules

So let’s get shot of poor-quality action theater, and opt for some real drama instead.

Johnnie Moore is a facilitator who has worked in Europe, North America, Africa and Asia. He’s co-author of Creative Facilation, a free book you can download at creativefacilitation.com/book.

Image via LeraBlog.

Advertising
Trending

How Indiegogo Is Becoming An Adult Product Destination

Retail
Home september 23, 2016

Watch This Fire Pit Dance Along To Your Favorite Song

Music City Fire is a system that is designed to flicker in time to ambient music

Automotive september 23, 2016

Slick GPS Navigator Gives Directions To Moped Riders

This small, round device attaches to a sideview mirror to display maps for safer traveling

Trending

Get PSFK's Related Report: Future of Work

See All
Home september 23, 2016

A Clock That Beautifully Manages Your Information Overload

The wall-mounted timekeeper is made to help people maintain focus and stay up to date with their appointments

Arts & Culture september 23, 2016

Performance Piece Blends Dancers Into Folds Of Light

The work provides commentary on the increasing connection between programmed and analog dimensions

Related Expert

Alexa von Tobel

Education, Investing, Customer Service

Design & Architecture september 23, 2016

Design Firm Adapts Childhood Homes For Unemployed Young Adults

The studio has unveiled three prototypes of transformed living spaces for people forced to move back in with their families

Health september 23, 2016

These Chocolate Squares Claim To Reverse The Aging Process

A group of researchers from Cambridge University have developed a candy bar that promises to give you a youthful glow

Cities september 23, 2016

Food-Producing Architecture Competition Seeks To Better Feed Cities

A design challenge in Copenhagen highlights the need and beauty of urban farming

PSFK LABS REPORT

Future Of Automotive
Scenarios Driving The Digital Transformation Of An Industry
NEW

PSFK Op-Ed september 23, 2016

Productivity Expert: The Magic Of The Five-Hour Workday

Stephan Aarstol, Founder of Tower Paddle Boards, explains why the modern notion of office hours needs to evolve

PSFK Labs september 22, 2016

The Future Of Work: Why Innovation Is Every Employee’s Job

PSFK Labs sits down with management at Johnson & Johnson to learn how the company comes up with their next ‘big idea’

Health september 23, 2016

Wearable Monitors Sun Exposure To Prevent Sunburn

The clip monitors UV rays to make sure you're not receiving too much sunlight

Culture september 23, 2016

This Exhibition’s Crowning Jewel Is An 18k Gold-Plated Toilet

The piece, titled 'America,' is meant to raise questions about the country's wealth inequality

Culture september 23, 2016

Match Up With Dates On Tinder Based On Your Music Preferences

A new partnership with Spotify lets people pair up based on shared tastes in artists

Entertainment september 23, 2016

Capture, Cut Up, And Configure Your World In 360 Degrees

To meet a booming 360 and VR video-capturing industry, a multimedia software company bolstered its media editing suite for 360-video creation

PSFK LABS REPORT

Future Of Work
Cultivating The Next Generation Of Leaders
NEW

Advertising september 23, 2016

Buy Movie Tickets Directly From Your Facebook Profile

The new feature is part of a campaign from Fandango to further imbed social media into the ticket vendor's digital presence

Asia september 23, 2016

Co-Working Space Brings The Calming Atmosphere Of Nature Indoors

An architectural firm in China has designed a new type of shared office that prioritizes the natural environment

Retail september 23, 2016

Live Beacon Simplifies Cloud Sharing For Businesses

The battery-powered device and smartphone app allow anyone to send location-specific content without the hassle of code or hardware

No search results found.