Which Commercials Dominated At The Super Bowl

Which Commercials Dominated At The Super Bowl

Which ads conquered the field with their funny or heartwarming displays and which failed to make the final cut.

Sara Roncero-Menendez
  • 3 february 2014

Another year, another Super Bowl filled with the year’s biggest and best ads from America’s most prominent companies. While the action on the field was almost a complete shutdown by the Seattle Seahawks, the staff of PSFK had a more rousing match over which ads rose above the rest.

For the Best Use of Furry Friends, the competition was as fierce as the Chobani bear, who ended up winning the Weirdest Ad award. However, that ad that made the best use of our societal love for cute critters didn’t make it to the screen during the game. Instead, CarMax’s puppy version of the slow clap commercial aired during Animal Planet’s puppy bowl.

Cuddly creatures weren’t the only ones causing a ton of buzz. Celebrity Cameos were a dime a dozen this year, highlighting a company’s profile by their ability to pull top talent. Tom Hiddleston, Ben Kingsley, and Mark Strong proved why British villains dominate in Jaguars, David Beckman bared all for H&M, and the men of Full House had a small reunion to ruin John Stamos’s chance at love and Dannon Oikos greek yogurt. The cameo that impressed the PSFK crowd the most however, was Bud Light’s massive array of stars, including the Terminator himself, Arnold Schwarzenegger.

The ads this year were not afraid to be self-referential or point out the typical flaws of a classic Super Bowl’s ad. Two companies chose to go with Non-Ads, talking about the commercial they would have made for the game but didn’t. While SodaStream made a valiant effort with a censored ad featuring Scarlett Johansson, it was Newcastle’s ad featuring Anna Kendrick that mastered the art of the non-ad, winning the unanimous support of the staff.

Many of the ads relied on the power of Music to make their statement. While the Ellen Degeneres-backed Beats Music showed off a variety of great tracks and Toyota has an original song played by the Muppets, neither could make it to the end zone. It was Sonos and their house full of music that challenged viewers to feel the sound and scored for the night.

While Film Trailers are less traditional in the Super Bowl commercial line-up, that didn’t mean the studios didn’t pull out all the stops to make football fans excited for their upcoming releases. While giant robots leveled cities in Transformers: Age of Extinction and Marvel’s Captain America 2 attempted to save the planet, it was The Amazing Spider-Man 2 that swung it’s way into victory by demonstrating its impressive array of villains and special effects.

No one saw Wonderful Pistachios coming, but the ad —  featuring the quick wit of Stephen Colbert and a silent, dapper eagle — snagged the Best Ad From An Underdog, but lost to the meme-filled commercial for Squarespace for Best Ad From A Newcomer. Radioshack broke away from the pack with the hilarious tribute to the 1980s, earning the title of Funniest Ad while Coca Cola’s America the Beautiful won in the Pulling on the Heartstrings category.

Everyone waited with baited breath to see who would grab the Best Oreo moment Award, referring to an ad or company that stole the show in the most expected way on social media. It was a battle to the bitter end until Esurance came in and promised $1.5 million to one lucky Twitter user who used the #EsuranceSave30 to attract thousands of participants.

Overall, the PSFK staff couldn’t settle on which ad was the Best of the Night. Team picks included commercials for TurboMax, Wonderful Pistachios, Toyota, and the Jerry Seinfeld webshow, Comedians in Cars Getting Coffee. With such an expansive variety of ads to choose from, there’s no clear top choice, and unlike football, there’s no way to take the game into overtime.

Image: Coca Cola


Why The Apple Watch Is Taking Foot In The Restaurant Industry

Technology Today

Google’s Gyroscopic Camera Lets You Shoot VR Content On Android

The experimental device called Sprayscape takes photos inside a sphere to create 360-degree virtual images

Syndicated Today

Why Fashion Labels Are Moving Away From Overt Branding

New research suggests brand are shying away from logos and flashy displays


Get PSFK's Related Report: Future of Automotive

See All
Fashion Today

Scientists Have Developed A Furry Wetsuit Material Inspired By Beavers

MIT researchers created the lighter and warmer fabric to maximize speed in the water and to keep swimmers dry

Related Expert

Halle Tecco

Health, Venture Capital, Technology

Advertising Today

Coca-Cola Has Created A Custom Gaming PC

Maingear developed a computer featuring a fully functional coke bottle water-cooling reservoir

Social Media Today

Chipotle’s New Weekly Show Broadcasts Over Snapchat

The Mexican fast food brand is trying to build goodwill with high school and college students through the social media platform

Media & Publishing Today

The NBA Is Filming Live Games With A Special Camera Just For Your Phone

Subscribers to League Pass can now access a feature called Mobile View, which is shot to be optimized for phones and tablets


Future Of Automotive
Scenarios Driving The Digital Transformation Of An Industry

PSFK Op-Ed october 26, 2016

Creative Leadership Expert: Experiencing A Seismic Shift From Brand Loyalty To Interface Loyalty

Marc Shillum, founder of Chief Creative Office, explains why product designers must rethink the way they capture consumer attention

PSFK Labs october 25, 2016

The Keys For Exceptional Performance On And Off The Field

PSFK Labs' new report highlights five important insights for businesses to perform better than the competition

AI Today

Film Touchingly Portrays The Challenge Of Relying On AI To Combat Loneliness

Director David Wilson takes viewers on a journey of the benefits and ultimate deficiencies of replacing human interaction with robots

Travel Today

Delta Lets Flyers Track Their Luggage From The Airplane To The Airport

The airline's new app allows customers to see exactly where their baggage is throughout their journey

Food Today

Chef Turns Invasive Species Into Delicious Sushi

Creator Bun Lai is adapting strange new ingredients for his menu, which responds to the ecological impact of overabundant creatures in the local environment

Gaming & Play Today

Build Your Own Subway System In This Minimalist Game

Mini Metro lets you design your own fully functional transit network, simulating the flow of urban commuters with pared-down visuals

Work Today

Keyboard Designed To Help Women Use More Assertive Language

The device is a commentary on gender roles in the workplace, and features easy access to "power verbs" that help reinforce a habit of being direct in writing

Arts & Culture Today

Spanish Artist Dreams Up What Animals Would Look Like In Modern Clothing

Yago Partal's portraits depict the fantasized style preferences of creatures worldwide, from an Arctic wolf to a zebra

Fitness & Sport Today

New Data Technologies Make Hyper-Personalized Training A Reality

The Sports Debrief from PSFK Labs looks at how analytics tools are being developed to optimize human performance across all industries

Technology Today

IBM Watson Helps Grammy-Winning Producer Craft An EP

The computer system's data technology generated musical scores for Alex Da Kid's first solo project

No search results found.